Monday, April 4, 2011

Quick Thoughts on "Barney's Version" (Richard J. Lewis, 2010)

I saw Barney's Version last week and I initially didn't know what to say about this film. It confused me somewhat, and while I enjoyed it in parts, I struggled to determine what the point of the film was, other than to provide a thoughtful meditation on the quirks of life, and how we interpret our lives once we see them coming to an end. I wasn't sure if this was the tale of a real-life individual, or the work of fiction - I soon learned that it was in fact based on the 1997 novel, Barney's Version, by the late Mordecai Richler, whom the film is dedicated to.

Written to be read as an autobiography of its central protagonist, Barney Panofsky (portrayed in the film by Paul Giamatti), the novel chronicles the bizarre successes and failures that make up his life. These events are recounted by the man from an elderly age, after he has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's Disease, which explains the memory lapses and footnote corrections by his son throughout the novel. His unreliability as a narrator is realized through the varying mental states of his character. Perhaps all these incredible events didn't quite happen like he says.

The film works in the same way, opening with an elderly Barney, with each recounted chapter of his life sparked by an image or his recognition of an object. We are taken on a turbulent journey through Barney's life, stretching from his late twenties, living in Rome, to his middle-age in Montreal, Canada. As an overweight, cigar smoking and heavy drinking television producer (for Totally Unnecessary Productions) and hockey fanatic, Barney is a loathsome man, but throughout his life he is prone to acts of surprising generosity and kindness, especially towards his third wife and mother of his children, Miriam (Rosamund Pike).

I didn't especially like Barney, but through Giamatti's wonderful performance, you begin to warm to him. After briefly marrying Clara (Rachel Lefevre) when living in Rome, he returns to Canada and marries his second wife (Minnie Driver). It is at their lavish Jewish wedding that Barney meets and starts pursuing Miriam, spelling impending doom to this marriage also. Riddled throughout his marriages are Barney's friendships with Boogie (Scott Speedman), a promising young writer, and his father Izzy (Dustin Hoffman). Boogie's untimely death results in a murder investigation, with Barney finding himself the chief suspect at the time.

The best moments, and certainly the funniest, are when Izzy and Barney share the screen. Hoffman is a delight. Actually, the casting is perfect. Giamatti deservedly received recognition for his excellent performance, picking up a Golden Globe (Musical/Comedy). You might question why it has been classified as a comedy in the first place, though. Following Harvey Pekar (American Splendor) and Miles from Sideways, Panofsky ranks amongst Gimatti's best roles, whose ordinary everyday-guy boisterousness and obnoxiousness make room for surprising gifts of heart and sentimentalism. Hoffman, Minnie Driver and Rosamund Pike are also very good in support. 

As much as this film wanted to be a triumphant ode to the quirks of life, I wasn't absorbed or overly entertained throughout. The rest of my audience, mostly elderly people, were really entertained. The words 'beautiful' and 'moving' were amongst the the post-film discussion. But overall, I have to claim Barney's Version was unsatisfying and irrelevant.

My Rating: 3 Stars (C+)

Friday, April 1, 2011

New Release Review: The Lincoln Lawyer (Brad Furman, 2011)

The Lincoln Lawyer is the recent film adaptation of the 16th novel by American crime writer Michael Connelly. Adapted by John Romano, the film directed by Brad Furman and stars Matthew McConaughey. Fifteen years have passed since McConaughey appeared in Joel Schumacher's John Grisham adaptation, A Time to Kill, were he played an earnest, clean-cut defense attorney. This is arguably one of his finest roles, which has been followed by a string of rom-coms and action flops. But he is back in form here in The Lincoln Lawyer, playing a suave, charismatic but morally questionable Los Angeles County criminal defense attorney. This is the second adaptation of the work of the prolific crime fiction writer, following the fairly uninteresting Blood Work, directed by Clint Eastwood. This Connelly adaptation matches the engaging page-turning nature of the novel and delivers an absorbing, energetically paced and entertaining experience. While it offers few twists on the tired courtroom drama genre, its an effective thriller with solid performances that stands tall amongst recent outings.


McConaughey plays Mickey Haller, a moderately successful criminal defense attorney, who operates predominantly out of his Lincoln Sedan, driven by a former client working off his legal fees. He has built a reputation ensuring that even his most guilty client are acquitted, which is paraded around on his Lincoln's numberplate (NTGUILTY). As an arrogant, street-smart attorney, Haller has built his career defending the city's lowlifes and dealing with the city's seedy underworld, and in the opening sequences he calmly smooths out a few client problems with quick thinking, fast talking and a cheeky grin, before he is thrust the case of his career, that of Louis Roulet (Ryan Phillippe). Roulet is a wealthy Beverly Hills Playboy and son of a Real Estate Mogul, who is accused of the brutal beating, rape and attempted murder of a prostitute. Haller's morally questionable professionalism is neither unethical nor corrupt, but has resulted in a uniform dislike for him amongst the city's law enforcement, and the separation from his State Prosecutor ex-wife, Maggie McPherson (Marissa Tomei). This is a man who knows that his clients are guilty, but he works to ensure they return to the streets (or given a lesser sentence). For Haller, an innocent client is scary. If he were to lose a case and his client found guilty, he would need to live with that for the rest of his life. How many points for guessing if this emerges as a theme?

Haller finally meets his match with Roulet, which at first appears to be a straightforward case. Roulet claims that he was lured by the prostitute in the bar to her home for sexual favors, only to be beaten on entry and framed for the crime. It becomes a case to prove the victim was in fact after his wealth, when suing for damages. Haller and his private investigator Frank Levin (an always solid William H. Macy) analyze the evidence and find startling similarities to one of Haller's previous cases, a crime his client Jesus Martinez (Michael Pena) was encouraged by Haller to plead guilty to, despite his insistence that he was innocent. With the Prosecution set to recommend the Death Penalty to Martinez, and with Haller convinced the evidence suggested the man was guilty, he encourages Martinez to confess and take a life sentence. But is Roulet innocent after all? Why didn't he admit to having a knife on his person, the same one found bloodied at the crime scene? His explanation to everything is to claim he has no memory of the event, and that the evidence is staged. Roulet is shady from the beginning, and appears to be working far too hard to prove his innocence. Haller is experienced and savvy and soon develops his suspicions about Roulet's true involvement. This is okay, he has had guilty clients acquitted before. But guilty clients who may have also killed his partner? No no. Haller, despite his personal feelings, is obliged to do his best for his client, with his hands tied by attorney-client confidentiality. Haller, amidst romantic flings with his ex-wife, duels with State Prosecutor Ted Minton (Josh Lucas), an additional unnecessary antagonist throughout the concluding courtroom sequences. It's frenetic, watchable popcorn drama.


While The Lincoln Lawyer is certainly not groundbreaking; offering up the typical structure of the legal thriller, it is energetically paced, tightly scripted (for the most part), well acted and genuinely entertaining. It loses direction there for a while and the plot contrivances begin to show in the final third, which is naturally full of cliches. We begin to question the motive behind the crime, and try to remember what happened to the supporting characters. There are a few surprises along the way but they are all fairly predictable, and it could have done with one less denouement. The soundtrack is pretty good, using a mix of hip hop and rap songs to pump up the audience during the opening credits, which make the only real use of the Lincoln, via some inventive shots. We are immediately thrust into Haller's world, the back of his Lincoln, but it becomes more of a useless plot device the further the film proceeds. I was actually a little bit concerned early when I saw some of the camerawork. It was full of awkward extreme close-ups, shaky reverse tracking and overenthusiastic zooms. I'm not sure if Furman was trying to do something different, but either it settled down throughout the film, or I was distracted less. Some of the cinematography and editing just seemed out-of-place to add unnecessary dynamics.


McConaughey certainly looks like he has something to prove here, and he delivers one of his best performances since A Time to Kill. He is mature and charismatic as a charming hustler, who becomes emotionally consumed with regret and frustration. He hides his boiling hatred beneath his professional exterior. Pushed to the edge, his life (and that of his family's) is threatened and for the first time he finds that his legal skills have been manipulated and challenged. He is rarely off screen and very competently carries the film and drives it through its twists and turns. The supporting cast are all quite good, if only making up stock complementary roles. Ryan Phillippe, who is usually cast in cold-hearted dramatic roles these days, is pretty wooden, and I didn't think he was convincing anyone he was innocent. Marissa Tomei, William H. Macy, Michael Pena, John Leguizamo (what did that guy do?) and Bryan Cranston are all relegated to a scene here and there. With the exception of William H. Macy, most of their stories are quickly brushed over at the conclusion in passing.

Overall, I was pleasantly surprised by The Lincoln Lawyer. Its an engrossing, intelligent thriller that makes good use of Connelly's best-selling source material. Cutting down a complex narrative is always a challenge, but I think it's quite well done. I haven't seen many recent courtroom dramas recently; once upon a time studios were relentless with their production. While very watchable, they tend to often offer up the same old tricks. If you choose to ignore some of the incredible plot developments, The Lincoln Lawyer has some fine moments, and certainly worth a visit to the cinema.

My Rating: 3 1/2 Stars (B-)

The Best Films I Saw in March

I watched a total of 26 films in March, up from my effort in February. I tried to see as many new releases as possible, but managed to avoid the critically-panned stinkers Battle: Los Angeles and Red Riding Hood.

New Releases (Cinema): Conviction (Tony Goldwyn, 2010), The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest (Daniel Alfredson, 2010), The Adjustment Bureau (George Nolfi, 2011), Hall Pass (Farrely Brothers, 2011), Rango (Gore Verbinski, 2011), Limitless (Neil Burger, 2011), The Mechanic (Simon West, 2011), Waiting for Superman (Davis Guggenheim, 2010), Barney's Version (Richard J. Lewis, 2010), Griff the Invisible (Leon Ford, 2011, The Lincoln Lawyer (Brad Furman, 2011)

Watched First Time (TV/DVD): Man With a Movie Camera (Dziga Vertov, 1929), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Tobe Hooper, 1974), The Day The Earth Stood Still (Scott Derrickson, 2008)

Re-watched (DVD): M (Fritz Lang, 1931), The Apartment (Billy Wilder, 1960), Aguirre: The Wrath of God (Werner Herzog, 1972), Annie Hall (Woody Allen, 1977), American Beauty (Sam Mendes, 1999), 28 Days Later (Danny Boyle, 2002), Brokeback Mountain (Ang Lee, 2005), The Bourne Ultimatum (Paul Greengrass, 2007), The Hurt Locker (Kathryn Bigalow, 2009), Shutter Island (Martin Scorsese, 2010), Let Me In (Matt Reeves, 2010) and The Social Network (David Fincher, 2010).

Essential Viewing


Man With a Movie Camera (Dziga Vertov, 1929)


M (Fritz Lang, 1931)


The Apartment (Billy Wilder, 1960)


Aguirre: The Wrath of Gold (Werner Herzog, 1972)


Annie Hall (Woody Allen, 1977)


American Beauty (Sam Mendes, 1999)


Brokeback Mountain (Ang Lee, 2005)


The Bourne Ultimatum (Paul Greengrass, 2007)


The Hurt Locker (Kathryn Bigalow, 2009)


The Social Network (David Fincher, 2010)


Rango (Gore Verbinski, 2011)

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Monster Inc. Prequel Title Announced


The confirmed sequel to beloved Pixar classic Monsters Inc. from 2001 will in fact be a prequel, titled Monsters University. With Billy Crystal and John Goodman reprising the voice-roles of Mike and Sulley, the events will chronicle the pair's studies at the University of Fear (before they begin working at the factory) where their friendship originates. While I am feeling indifferent about Cars 2 this year, Monsters University sounds like a pretty cool idea. Big thanks to Jack Ibbetson at So I Saw this Film... for making me aware of this announcement.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Releases 31/03

 
Getting in slightly early this week, here are the March 31st releases: 

Just Go With It: A comedy starring both Adam Sandler and Jennifer Anniston. This is reason enough to keep clear. This sounds ridiculous, predictable, juvenile and another dire addition to the rom-com genre.

Rotten Tomatoes: 18%

Never Let Me Go: The screen adaptation of the acclaimed Kazuo Ishiguro novel, Never Let Me Go stars the wonderful young talents of Carey Mulligan, Andrew Garfield and to a lesser extent, Keira Knightley. It tells the tragic tale of a love triangle between three young people, who share their childhood together at what first appears to be an idyllic English boarding school. But the shocking truth of their existence is withheld from them. They re-unite as adults to face the dark secrets tied to their communal past. The Mark Romanek film has appeared on several critics Top 10 lists and should be a rewarding experience.

Rotten Tomatoes: 69%

The Lincoln Lawyer: The new film starring Matthew McConaughey (whose best work is arguably his role as a lawyer in the John Grisham adaptation, A Time to Kill). He stars in The Lincoln Lawyer as Mickey Haller, a Los Angeles criminal defense attorney who primarily operates out of the back of his Lincoln sedan. Haller has spent most of his career defending garden-variety criminals, until he lands the case of his career; defending Louis Roulet (Ryan Phillippe), a Beverly Hills playboy accused of rape and attempted murder. Based on the Michael Connelly novel, The Lincoln Lawyer likely won't offer any twists on the courtroom drama, but, much like Connelly's novel, should be fast-paced and engaging. McConaughey has to prove himself again, but the support cast is solid.

Rotten Tomatoes: 82%

In A Better World: Directed by Sussanne Bier and winner of Best Foreign Language Film for Denmark at both the Golden Globes and Academy Awards. Anton is a doctor who commutes between his home town in Denmark and his work at an African refugee camp. In these two very different worlds, he and his family are faced with conflicts that lead them to difficult choices between revenge and forgiveness. Sure to be a complex, thought-provoking, raw, emotional and above all important human drama.

Rotten Tomatoes: 79%

Heartbeats: 21-year-old filmmaker Xavier Dolan's second film, Heartbeats, was a hit at the Cannes Film Festival and voted the audience favorite at last years Sydney Film Festival. It centers on two close friends, Francis (Xavier Dolan) and Marie (Monia Chokri), who find themselves fighting for the affections of the same young man. The more intimate the trio becomes, the more unattainable the object of their infatuation seems. Sexy, stylish and farcical are words used to describe Heartbeats.

Rotten Tomatoes: 74%

Weekly Recommendation: Strong week this week. With the exception of Just Go With It, I think all of the films are worth a look. Heartbeats is playing at limited cinemas, but I will endeavor to see the other three. The Lincoln Lawyer should be safe entertainment, but I don't think Never Let Me Go or In a Better World will be disappointing either. Happy viewing!

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Feature Article: A Conundrum for Cultural Critics


Cultural criticism is a key facet of media journalism and one that is regularly and readily consumed by the general public. Many people make it their business to be educated about the cultural world around them, whether they are seeking a recommendation for an ideal film to see on their Friday night date, whether the new Sue Grafton novel is as page-turning as her previous work, or how their new favorite restaurant has fared upon critical review. Critical reviews are just as consumable as the texts or experiences they document. Many consumers read these reviews and analyses to ensure they make an educated cultural decision. With swift inflation, not everybody can afford to outlay regular cultural expense. Others are interested in comparing their own opinions of the texts with those of the published writers. But what has emerged as the most widely accessed and publicly trafficked medium to write and report through? Many cultural critics are becoming less and less convinced about the predominant origins of their readers. Is the rising storm of online criticism and blogging placing more professional, and better-respected modes of mainstream communications at risk?

As an amateur film and entertainment critic and avid blogger, do I expect as many readers to pass through my blog (amidst thousands of competing critics and blogs) as say listen to the weekly reviews over the radio, or tune into the weekly television slot for At the Movies? Not a chance. I thought I’d ask some of the online community’s leading film bloggers their opinions on the growth of online cultural criticism and how much of their readership is outside of the blogging network. I also thought it would be interesting to investigate the success of promoting ones work over social networking giants like Facebook and Twitter. While certainly not attracting the coverage of mainstream media, many would argue they still possess beneficial means of promoting ones business and widely relaying your cultural opinions and personal agendas.

I spoke to Ryan Helms, an avid and successful film blogger, whose fantastic website, A Life in Equinox, is one of the most respected sources of insightful film knowledge on the Internet. He believes, “Blogging is arguably the most internationally accessible medium by which one can openly discuss varying aspects of their society” but he argues that “it is also the most turbulent and unpredictable.”  For a film blogger, to receive 1,000 hits for a single day might seem like a big deal. But compare that to a daily newspaper, which is bought and read by millions of people. The coverage is incomparable. A swift response to the article is only a short click away, which means that bloggers are often subject to angry and malicious rants into empty cyberspace. Alternatively, a dedicated critic may also benefit from a wealth of positive response, which will ultimately prove beneficial for someone working online to hone his or her writing skills.

Someone who reads a review in the paper really has limited means to communicate with the writer. Helms also declared, that “it requires a certain work ethic to establish and maintain a blog that maintains an air of respect among ‘professional’ media outlets.” With plenty of room for error and growth, many cultural bloggers are un-paid, semi-professional writers tackling the vast cyber expanse of the World Wide Web to develop their skills and have their work exposed for evaluation in a public forum. Comparatively, there is often immense pressure on a print or television journalist when faced with a one-shot article. Most film and entertainment critics working under contract with leading editorials also post a copy of their work under the related website, and their opinions are merged into a collaboration for entertainment sites such as Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic. So even if their desired mode of reporting is through print, it is essential they cater for the inevitable growth of online readership.  Thomas Caldwell, radio film critic with Triple R and a contributor for The Big Issue agrees, “It is hard to find decent online work that’s not connected to an established source or by somebody who already has a presence in traditional media and sees online as an extension of their profile."

Tom Clift, an emerging film critic from Melbourne and a contributing writer for Row Three and Flickchart agrees, “There still tends to be a certain prestige associated with print media” and “from a writers point of view, there is certainly some amount of pride in seeing your name in print.” Predominantly a working online critic, Tom “turns to blogs and websites for almost all cultural criticism, for two key reasons: convenience and diversity.”  There is no debating the wealth of material available online, but the issue is, of course, discerning between the quality of the contributions. Anders Wotzke, a leading Australian film critic, editor-in-chief of Cut Print Review and member of the Online Film Critics Society, argues, “In traditional media, professional standards – a sense of quality control – still apply. For employed print critics, their work is their livelihood, rather than a hobby or a casual job.” Anders also believes that this will change. “As we begin to tame the Internet,” he states, “I’m certain online critics will be just as reputable as those in print, if not more so.” Caldwell also argues, “Traditional media seems to be increasingly disinterested in serious writing about cinema and it’s certainly viewed more as entertaining reporting than cultural criticism” which tends to suggest that the credibility of a high percentage of online criticism is not as low as many believe.

As for the exposure on Social Networking sites like Facebook, I am not yet convinced that there is any benefit to this strategy. It is a great way to keep your acquaintances and regular readers informed about new articles and developments in your work. But in terms of attracting new readers, I have found that many followers will be linked to Facebook, having already followed the site. Twitter makes it so easy to communicate with individuals of similar professional interests, and joining a large online community is an essential way of building recognition within your chosen industry. Most cultural critics will agree that trying a hand in different mediums is helpful to finding an appreciative audience. As Wotzke states: “Unlike in print, where your audience is only as big as the number of copies you print, there is a limitless supply of readers, watchers and listeners waiting online to be reached.” As a motivated hard-working online critic myself, this is great news. The skill-set of the 21st Century cultural critic now requires a diverse portfolio of talents to ensure professional recognition, but amidst the desire to be widely published, the choice of medium to target has presented a conundrum for agents of cultural criticism. 

What are your thoughts? 

New Release Review: Waiting for Superman (Davis Guggenheim, 2010)

Award-winning documentary Waiting for Superman is an engrossing and comprehensive insight into the failures of the public education system in the United States. Director David Guggenheim (An Inconvenient Truth), through his tracking of five children through their school experiences, seeks to reveal and analyze the ways the system is failing, and interviews several education reformers about the inventive methods they believe can fix the problem.

For three of the children; Anthony, Daisy and Emily, their commitment to learning and desire to escape the public system and attend college is uplifting and inspiring. Anthony is in the fifth grade at a public school in Washington D.C, which is rated one of the worst in the country. Having lost his father to drug use, he wants to grow up and be successful and create a childhood for his own children superior to his own. Daisy, who resides in East L.A, has already written to the medical school she wishes to attend in the future. While driven to learn all that she can, the failures of her school will seriously jeopardize her chances of making it to college. Emily's poor math marks at her Silicon Valley school will likely relegate her to a lower academic stream, and little prospect of choosing the college of her choice. For first-graders Bianca and Francisco, Guggenheim speaks more to their mothers, who are desperately trying to find alternative education for their children. Bianca lives in Harlem, where her mother is struggling to pay the tuition fees at her local Catholic School because she doesn't feel comfortable sending her daughter to the public one. While Francisco's mother works hard with him at their Bronx home, only to discover that he has experienced early struggles at school. With nowhere else to turn, each of these families decide to apply for the admission of their children to the independently-run Charter Schools set up in disadvantaged areas by visionary educational reformers. But the competition is fierce, with only limited spots available, and whether these children are accepted or not is decided by a public lottery.


To think that whether or not these children will receive adequate education is decided by a bouncing ball, or a random assignment, is tremendously troubling. You would think, in a developed country like America, that every child would have the right to quality education. The film examines a variety of reasons to stipulate why this is the case. Poor funding, overcrowded classrooms, unfairly scaled grading, teacher incompetency in addition to the children's broken homes are all thrown around as reasons why the system is failing. Guggenheim quickly establishes that it would take someone with superhuman powers to fix this gargantuan problem, and because none like Superman exist, it appears to be solely up to the founders of these independent school networks, and headstrong revolutionary chancellors like Michelle Rhee. Rhee, during her term, outraged the Teachers Unions by closing schools, firing principles and attempting to overturn contracts of Tenure. One of the most passionate and inspiring characters is Geoffrey Canada, who runs a Charter school covering an impoverished area of Harlem. He lengthens the school day and year, has smaller class sizes and employs quality teachers for tuition. The greatest moments of the film stem from his confidence that he can transform a struggling and disadvantaged child into a college graduate. The academic results of the Charter schools, as expressed in the film, are better than even higher-funded and expensive private schools. The credibility of these statistics has been the front of controversy since the film's release, though.


To complement the footage of the children, and the accounts of Canada, Rhee and Bill Gates are a series of animated graphics to assist us to digest the often-horrifying statistics. Among these are the revelations about the plummeting reading and math levels of children across the country, and comparisons made between the money spent on catering for school dropouts who end up in prison versus the cost of a year of private school tuition. The film's climax is the most heartbreaking of all. As we see the five families attend their separate lotteries, hoping desperately to hear their number called. Perhaps their lives will be changed forever. The disappointment on the faces of the unlucky ones will resonate with viewers long after the final credits. Waiting for Superman is engrossing, maddening, uplifting and ultimately heartbreaking. A very well made documentary that tackles very troubling issues. Despite centering its view on American schools, the desperation of their families, especially Bianca's and Francisco's mothers, will be appreciated by anyone. Certainly worth a look.

My Rating: 4 Stars (B)

Monday, March 28, 2011

Short Review: Broken Flowers (Jim Jarmusch, 2005)

This a bizarre film. Timed to near-perfection the seemingly meandering plot is full of surprises and a series of brilliant performances. Bill Murray (in a role rivaling his nominated performance in Lost in Translation), Jeffrey Wright (hilarious as his sleuth-obsessed neighbor Winston), and Sharon Stone, Francis Conroy and Jessica Lange as the ex-girlfriends he visits, are all fantastic. Broken Flowers is a film that demands your attention but subtly rewards you with a series of entertaining encounters between Bill Murray and a variety of unique individuals as he partakes his road-trip. His mission is to discover which of his ex-flames had communicated with him via a pink letter about a son he never knew existed. Murray's world-weary, disinterested expression throughout the film is also very amusing. The flashing drive-by cinematography is beautiful and the soundtrack very unique. Broken Flowers was a hit at the 2005 Cannes Film Festival and now after my third viewing - yes, I admit it takes a few to grasp, I can certainly recommend it.

My Rating: 4 Stars (B+)